Read the claim before opening the link. Identify the exact proposition, then check whether the source contains that proposition rather than merely discussing the same topic.
Check timing and context. A current article may rely on an older statistic, a different population, or a changed definition. Preserve the original date and explain why it remains useful.
Flag interpretation as interpretation. Editors can keep a reasoned implication, but should not present a source’s observation as proof of a broader business outcome.
When a citation fails review, narrow the sentence, find a stronger source, or remove the claim. Record the decision so the same question is not reopened without new evidence.