Research question and scope
This protocol measures how often a freight damage claim reaches the logistics desk without the required photo evidence. The unit is one claim file tied to one delivery. A missing set means the file lacks the wide, close, or packaging photo the intake checklist requires. The measure describes the intake control, not the validity of the damage.
Set the scope to one warehouse, one carrier set, and a fixed period. Record the photo requirements in force and the claim system used. If the checklist changes during the period, split the sample at the effective date. A different requirement creates a different denominator.
Keep the measure separate from a recovery rate. A claim can have complete photos and still be denied for a late filing. The purpose is to test the evidence at intake. Report recovery separately.
Population and unit of analysis
Define the population as every damage claim file opened during the period. Include claims that were paid, denied, and withdrawn. The unit is the claim file, not each photo or each parcel line. A shipment with three damaged cartons is one claim when the carrier records it as one.
Include claims opened from a customer report and claims opened from a dock inspection. Mark the source on each file. Exclude shortage claims with no physical damage, and report that count separately. The checklist for a shortage is not the same as the checklist for damage.
Exclude a duplicate claim opened against the same delivery and carrier reference. Link it to the original and count it once. Duplicate filing is a separate efficiency measure. State the exclusion count beside the denominator. Record the reason for each exclusion.
Definitions that make the measure reproducible
Define the required photo set as a wide shot, a close-up of the damage, and a photo of the packaging, all with original timestamps. Define a complete set as all three, a partial set as one or two, and a missing set as none. Publish one example of each before sampling. Keep the examples with the sampling rule so a new reviewer can use them.
Define the claim window as the carrier's written deadline for that service and delivery date. Define a late filing as a claim submitted after that deadline. A late claim is not a photo defect and should be reported separately. The two failures need different fixes.
Decide how to treat a video or a shared album in place of still photos. Count it as evidence only when the file is stored with the claim and can be reviewed later. A link that expires is not evidence. Record the storage method with the result.
Sampling and data collection
Draw the sample from the claim system and the intake queue for the full period. Record the export date, the filters, and the row count. Do not build the sample from denied claims alone. A denied-only sample cannot show the claims that succeeded without full evidence.
Capture the claim identifier, the delivery date, the carrier, the claim type, the photo count, the photo types, the file timestamps, the filing date, and the outcome. Add the replacement order number where one exists. Store the export with the report. The photo list and the timestamps are the core evidence.
Check a small overlap sample with a second reviewer. If the reviewers disagree about whether a close-up is adequate, the definition is too vague. Rewrite the rule and retest before the full sample. Agreement matters more than sample size.
Record the time spent opening each claim file to count the photos. A report that requires a manual review of every image will not be repeated. Note the claim fields that the carrier does not expose. The collection cost belongs beside the result.
Measuring missing photo evidence
Report the share of claims with a complete set, a partial set, and a missing set. Show the counts behind each share. The three groups describe different levels of evidence and should not be collapsed. A single missing-photo rate hides the claim that had one useful image.
Break the result down by carrier, claim type, and desk shift. A carrier with a strict portal may show more complete files. A night shift may photograph less because the dock light is poor. Compare only groups with similar volume and process.
Report the share of denials that cite missing evidence. Link each denial reason to the photo score for that file. A denial for a missing wide shot is an intake gap, while a denial for a late filing is a deadline gap. Report the two separately.
Report the age of each claim at filing and at review. A complete set filed on the last day is still a risk. Include the carrier deadline and the replacement cost. The distribution shows whether the problem is evidence or timing.
Limitations and next action
The measure cannot show whether the damage happened before or after handover. It also cannot show a photo that was taken but never uploaded. Treat the result as a measure of the claim file. Note the carriers and claim types that were not included.
Give the result to the logistics owner and the carrier contact with one change to test. The change might be a required photo field in the intake form, a dock checklist, or an earlier filing reminder. Record the effective date and repeat the measure with the same definitions. A controlled change is easier to judge.
Review the boundary cases before changing the whole checklist. A few carriers with a strict portal may explain a large share of complete files. Fix the requirement first if that is the pattern. The goal is a file that can support the claim, not a lower number by definition.
